Returns · 11 min read · Updated November 2026
IRR vs MOIC: What Each Private Equity Return Measures and When It Misleads
IRR vs MOIC with worked LBO math: what each return measures, how hold time and dividend recaps pull them apart, and how to say whether a return is good enough.
MOIC measures value per dollar invested. IRR measures the annual return implied by the timing of the cash flows. A dividend recap shows why both matter. In our distribution example, borrowing $60M for a year-three dividend raises the deal IRR from 25.1% to 27.7%, even though the sponsor receives $11.3M less in total.
In the base case, $80M invested and $245.3M returned five years later produces a 3.07x MOIC and 25.1% IRR. Receive the same proceeds two years earlier and the multiple stays at 3.07x, while IRR rises to 45.3%.
IRR vs MOIC: The Difference in One Table
IRR and MOIC are calculated from the same sponsor cash flows: the equity check at close, any distributions during the hold, and the exit proceeds, after debt and after any management equity plan. They answer different questions about those flows.
| MOIC (multiple on invested capital) | IRR (internal rate of return) | |
|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | How many dollars came back per dollar invested? | What annual rate did the money earn? |
| Formula | (Distributions + value still held) ÷ equity invested | The discount rate that makes the net present value of all cash flows zero |
| Sensitive to time? | No | Yes, heavily |
| Shows dollar profit? | No: $10 into $30 and $100 into $300 are both 3.0x | No: with the same timing, both earn the same IRR |
| Rewarded by | Holding longer and compounding value | Exiting sooner and distributing early |
| Can be raised without new profit by | Rarely | A recap, an early partial exit, or delaying when capital is called |
| Best used for | The size of the win and the risk of loss | Comparing deals with different hold periods, and against a hurdle |
| House case | 3.07x | 25.1% |
For a single deal, divide distributions plus the value of equity still held by total sponsor equity invested, including follow-ons. At the LP level, the comparable net multiple is TVPI: distributions plus net residual NAV divided by paid-in capital. Fees, expenses, carry, borrowing and the timing of capital calls can make the two differ. ILPA Performance Template
DPI uses cumulative LP distributions over the same paid-in denominator. A fund with $100 million paid in, $40 million distributed and $90 million residual NAV has 0.40x DPI and 1.30x TVPI. Of the value in that 1.30x, $90 million still depends on future realizations.
Same Multiple, Different Clock
For a single equity check and a single exit, the conversion is exact: IRR = MOIC^(1 / years) − 1. That formula is why the hold period matters as much as the multiple.
Horizontal bars showing the IRR of the same 3.07x multiple: 45.3% over three years, 25.1% over five years (highlighted), 17.4% over seven years.
The grid below is the version to memorize for a paper LBO. Read across a row to see what waiting costs.
| MOIC | 3-year hold | 4-year hold | 5-year hold | 7-year hold |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5x | 14.5% | 10.7% | 8.4% | 6.0% |
| 2.0x | 26.0% | 18.9% | 14.9% | 10.4% |
| 2.5x | 35.7% | 25.7% | 20.1% | 14.0% |
| 3.0x | 44.2% | 31.6% | 24.6% | 17.0% |
| 3.5x | 51.8% | 36.8% | 28.5% | 19.6% |
Two shortcuts follow from the grid. To clear a 25% IRR, a 2.0x deal has to exit within about 3.1 years and a 3.0x deal within about 4.9 years. At a 20% target the same multiples buy you about 3.8 and 6.0 years.
The house case, from cash flows to both metrics
The distribution case study buys Industrial Inc. at $150 million of enterprise value, or 6.0x $25 million of EBITDA. Uses also include $4.5 million of fees and $5 million of minimum operating cash. A $75 million term loan and $4.5 million opening revolver draw leave the sponsor funding $80 million of the $159.5 million of uses.
| Sponsor cash flow | Year 0 | Years 1 to 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equity invested | ($80.0M) | none | none |
| Exit equity | none | none | $245.3M |
- MOIC = $245.3M ÷ $80.0M = 3.07x.
- IRR: one check in, one check out, so IRR = 3.06625^(1/5) − 1 = 25.1%.
- Check the IRR. Discount $245.3M at the calculated annual rate (approximately 25.1185%) for five years. The present value is $80.0M. Using the rounded display rate of 25.1% gives about $80.1M.
The workbook rounds the multiple to 3.1x at one decimal place. The base case narrowly clears this exercise’s targets of 25.0% and 3.0x.
Four Ways IRR Misleads
IRR is the industry’s headline number, and most of its failures come from one property: it rewards the timing of cash, not only the amount.
1. It says nothing about what happens to early cash. IRR is solved from the cash flows alone; calculating it needs no reinvestment assumption. But an investor’s compounded return depends on what each distribution earns after it is paid out, and it equals the IRR only if every distribution keeps earning the IRR until the end. Ludovic Phalippou shows a fund that pays out early and posts a 68% IRR; if its distributions earn 12% instead, its modified IRR (MIRR) is 17% (Private Equity Mathematics, ch. 1, Table 1.1). MIRR makes the reinvestment rate an explicit input.
2. IRRs cannot be averaged. In the same table, four funds average a 21% IRR, but the IRR of their combined cash flows is 12%. For example, invest $100 in each of two deals today. One pays $200 in year one and the other pays $100 in year two. Their IRRs are 100% and 0%. Weighting by invested capital and years held gives 33.3%. The combined cash flows are −$200, +$200 and +$100, which earn 36.6%. Sum the cash flows on each date and calculate IRR for equal periods or XIRR for actual dates.
3. Short holds flatter it. A 1.5x in two years is a 22.5% IRR on a small profit. A sponsor that sells early to lock in a headline IRR may leave the larger multiple on the table, which is why investors look at MOIC and DPI beside it.
4. Changing the funding date changes the rate. A subscription line can delay an LP’s first capital call and lift a positive IRR, even after borrowing costs reduce the profit. Ask for the cash flows with and without the line. An earlier payout can also raise a positive return, depending on the financing cost and the ultimate exit proceeds.
A further check matters when a deal pays an early dividend and then needs rescue equity. Multiple changes of sign can produce more than one IRR. For annual flows of -$100, +$230 and -$132, both 10% and 20% set NPV to zero. Calculate NPV at the committee’s own rate and show the cash schedule.
When MOIC Misleads
MOIC fails in the opposite direction. It ignores time, so a 2.0x over ten years (a 7.2% IRR) and a 2.0x over three years (26.0%) print the same multiple. It ignores the cost of capital, so a slow multiple can lose to a public index while looking like a win. And it hides interim distributions, so two deals with the same 2.5x can return cash on very different schedules.
The fix is the same as for IRR: report the multiple with its hold period and its realized share, and read it next to the rate.
When a dividend recap raises IRR and lowers MOIC
A dividend recapitalization borrows new debt against the portfolio company and pays it out to the owners before exit. It moves cash earlier, which is exactly what IRR rewards, and it adds interest, which comes out of the exit.
Run it on the house case. In year three the company borrows $60 million at 9% and pays it to the sponsor. By the year-five exit, that debt plus accrued interest is about $71.3 million, which reduces exit equity from $245.3 million to about $174.0 million. (We let the recap loan’s interest accrue to exit and ignore its tax deduction, which keeps the arithmetic visible.)
| Sponsor result | No recap | Year-3 recap |
|---|---|---|
| Cash returned | $245.3M | $234.0M ($60.0M + $174.0M) |
| MOIC | 3.07x | 2.93x |
| IRR | 25.1% | 27.7% |
| Compounded return (MIRR) if the $60M earns 8% until year 5 | 25.1% | 25.0% |
The recap adds 2.6 percentage points of IRR and costs $11.3M in total proceeds. If the $60M dividend earns 8% until year five, total terminal wealth is $244.0M. The investor’s compounded annual return is 25.0%, just below the no-recap result. An investment committee deciding between the two needs both the debt cost and the return it expects on the cash paid out.
What Counts as a Good IRR or MOIC?
A return is only good against a bar, and the bar depends on the basis. State the basis first:
- Deal or fund. Deal-level returns are one company’s sponsor cash flows. Fund-level returns pool every deal and include the cost of the losers.
- Gross or net. A sponsor’s deal return uses its investment and exit proceeds. A net LP return uses the investor’s calls, distributions and remaining interest after fees and carry. Check which cash-flow series each number describes.
- Hold and timing. Count from the closing date to the exit, with interim distributions where they happen.
With the basis stated, three bars are common:
| Bar | What it is | How to use it |
|---|---|---|
| The firm’s target | The deal-level gross IRR and MOIC the investment committee expects in the base case | Clear it in the base case and know what breaks it |
| The fund’s hurdle | The preferred return specified in the partnership agreement, if applicable | Read the waterfall and catch-up provisions before calculating carry. |
| The cost of the equity | What the same money could earn elsewhere at similar risk | The economic test behind the other two |
If a partnership agreement specifies an 8% preferred return, it is an input to that fund’s waterfall. Check the rate, compounding and catch-up language. The worked acquisition uses separate, illustrative investment committee targets of 25% gross deal IRR and 3.0x MOIC.
How to Answer “Is This Return Good Enough?”
The free test on this site ends with that question, and most first drafts answer it with a number alone. A complete answer has four parts:
- Both metrics, with the basis: “3.1x and 25% gross, deal level, five years from close.”
- The bar: “That clears a 25% and 3.0x target, narrowly.”
- Where the return comes from: EBITDA growth, debt paydown and any change in multiple. A return that depends on multiple expansion is weaker than one that depends on cash.
- What would break it: “Hold one more year for the same proceeds and the IRR falls to about 20.5%. Exit at 5.0x instead of 6.0x and the multiple drops to about 2.6x, with an IRR near 21%.”
That last line is the one reviewers remember, because it shows you know which assumption the return depends on.
IRR and MOIC traps
| Trap | What goes wrong | How to catch it | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quoting IRR without the hold | A 40% IRR from an 18-month flip is compared with a 25% IRR from a five-year hold. | Ask for the MOIC and the dates beside every IRR. | Report IRR, MOIC and hold period together, from closing date to exit. |
| Averaging IRRs | Deal IRRs of 45%, 20% and 5% are reported as a 23% portfolio return. | Recompute from the pooled cash flows. | Sum the cash flows for each date, then calculate IRR for equal periods or XIRR for the actual dates. |
| Counting from the model's year 0 instead of close | A mid-year close is treated as a full extra year, or a stub period is dropped. | Check the dates in XIRR against the closing date in the assignment. | Use XIRR with real dates whenever cash flows are irregular. |
| Treating a recap as value creation | IRR rises after a recap and the memo calls the deal stronger. | Compare total cash returned before and after the recap. | Show MOIC and the effective return at a stated reinvestment rate. |
| Mixing gross and net | A deal's gross IRR is compared with a fund's net IRR or a public index. | Label every figure gross or net, deal or fund. | Compare like with like, and show fees and carry as a bridge when it matters. |
Before you report a return
- Both metrics: IRR and MOIC, never one alone.
- Basis: deal or fund, gross or net, realized or including unrealized value.
- Dates: closing date to exit, with XIRR for irregular cash flows.
- Interim cash: recaps, partial exits and fees shown where they happen.
- The bar: the target, hurdle or cost of equity you are comparing against.
- The break point: the hold, exit multiple or EBITDA that takes the return below the bar.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between IRR and MOIC? MOIC (multiple on invested capital) measures how much value comes back per dollar invested: distributions plus the value of anything still held, divided by equity invested. IRR (internal rate of return) measures how fast: the annual discount rate that sets the net present value of every sponsor cash flow to zero. MOIC ignores time. Neither shows dollar profit, and neither changes when a deal is scaled up or down in proportion.
Is a 2.0x MOIC good? It depends on the hold. A 2.0x over three years is about a 26% IRR; over five years it is about 14.9%; over seven years it is about 10.4%. A sponsor targeting a 25% IRR has to exit a 2.0x deal within about 3.1 years.
What is a good IRR for a private equity deal? State the cash-flow basis, hold period and investment committee’s required return. This worked case uses a 25% gross deal IRR and a 3.0x MOIC target. A fund’s preferred return is a separate term in the partnership agreement.
Why do private equity firms report both IRR and MOIC? Because each one can be gamed without the other. A short hold or an early distribution can lift IRR while the money returned stays small; a long hold can produce a large multiple at a weak annual rate. Reporting both, on a stated basis and hold period, shows the size and the speed of the return together.
Does a dividend recap increase IRR? Often, while lowering MOIC and the total cash the sponsor receives. In an illustration on the house case, a $60 million recap in year three raises the sponsor IRR from 25.1% to 27.7%, while total proceeds fall from $245.3 million to $234.0 million and the multiple from 3.07x to 2.93x, because the new debt and its interest come out of exit proceeds.
How do you convert MOIC to IRR quickly? For a single investment and a single exit, IRR equals MOIC raised to the power of one over the hold in years, minus one. Useful anchors: 2.0x in three years is about 26%, 2.0x in five years is about 15%, 3.0x in five years is about 25%.
Does IRR assume distributions are reinvested at the IRR? Not to be calculated: IRR is solved from the cash flows alone. It equals an investor’s compounded return only if early distributions keep earning the IRR until the end. In Ludovic Phalippou’s example, a fund with a 68% IRR has a 17% modified IRR (MIRR) when its distributions earn 12% instead.
Sources
Books:
- Ludovic Phalippou, “Measuring private equity performance: a closer look,” chapter 1 in Oliver Gottschalg (ed.), Private Equity Mathematics (PEI Media, 2009), Tables 1.1 and 1.2: reinvestment and MIRR (a 68% IRR fund is a 17% MIRR at a 12% reinvestment rate), and why averaged or pooled IRRs mislead (a 21% average IRR against 12% on the combined cash flows).
Reporting standards:
- ILPA Performance Template, for funds commencing operations from January 2026. The fund-level and portfolio-level cash-flow bases are separate.
Our calculations:
- The house case: PE Case Study: $150M Distribution LBO. The 3.07x and 25.1% are the case’s; the hold-period and recap figures are our own arithmetic on its $80 million in and $245.3 million out.
- Definitions: IRR and MOIC; calculators in the Returns Lab.
An exit proceeds waterfall, with IRR and MOIC sensitivity tables
One line of the assignment, at the end of a three-hour build from a blank workbook.
Revision History
- : Tied entry funding, exit proceeds and recap calculations to the current distribution workbook and added a two-root IRR check.
- : Added a two-deal example showing how to calculate combined IRR from dated cash flows.
- : First published, with worked examples on the house distribution case.