Debt · 9 min read · Updated November 2026

Senior vs Subordinated Debt in an LBO: Ranking, Pricing and Who Gets Paid

Senior vs subordinated debt in an LBO: payment, lien and structural priority, how each tranche is priced, and who recovers what if the deal goes wrong.

On this page 7 sections

Start with three questions: which company borrowed, what collateral secures the loan, and whose payment the contract puts first? Senior unsecured debt can outrank junior unsecured notes while still recovering less than a secured lender on its collateral. While the company is healthy, subordinated lenders usually still receive their interest, as far as the senior loan agreement and the intercreditor agreement allow; those agreements can block junior payments once the senior debt is in default. Priority itself comes in three forms that are easy to confuse: payment priority set by contract, lien priority over specific collateral, and structural priority, set by which company in the group owes the debt.

On a version of the house case with $60 million of senior debt and $20 million of 12% subordinated notes, a sale at $70 million repays the senior lenders in full, the subordinated lenders half, and the equity nothing. The same subordinated notes, used instead of $20 million more equity, lift the sponsor’s base case IRR from 22.1% to 24.8% on our teaching schedule (assumptions below).

The LBO Capital Stack, From Senior to Equity

Each layer of an LBO’s financing has a different claim, price and set of protections. The overview below summarizes a teaching exhibit in Private Equity in Action (Zeisberger, Prahl and White, 2017, Case 12, Exhibit 12.6). Treat it as a pattern, not current market terms.

Tranche Ranking and security Rate Repayment Covenants
Revolver Senior secured Lowest, floating No amortization; prepayable Maintenance
Term loan A Senior secured Low, floating Straight-line amortization Maintenance
Term loan B Senior secured Higher, floating Minimal amortization Maintenance in the historical example. Institutional term loans can be covenant-lite.
Senior notes Senior unsecured, sometimes secured Higher, fixed Bullet, call protection Incurrence
Subordinated notes Senior subordinated, unsecured Higher, fixed Bullet, call protection Incurrence
Mezzanine Subordinated, closest to equity Highest, fixed; cash or PIK Bullet, call protection Incurrence
Shareholder loans and equity Last The residual, shared with any management plan At exit None

Seniority fixes priority in the capital structure. The credit agreement determines which financial tests apply. A senior secured institutional term loan can use incurrence covenants even where the revolver has a maintenance test. See Boston Fed research on leveraged-loan covenants.

Real pricing makes the gradient concrete. In KKR and Silver Lake’s 2005 buyout of Agilent’s semiconductor group, the bank loans were priced at LIBOR + 250 basis points, the senior floating notes at LIBOR + 550, the senior fixed notes at 10.125% and the senior subordinated notes at 11.875% (Case 12, Exhibit 12.7). Avago’s own offering document confirms both fixed coupons and the floating-note spread. These are historical LIBOR terms. For dated middle-market financing evidence, see the 2026 terms block in our LBO build guide.

One column in the table is easy to misread. PIK is a way of paying interest, not a rank: a senior loan can carry a PIK option, and a subordinated note can pay all of its interest in cash. Where a tranche ranks comes from its documents and from the company that borrows it.

Payment, Lien and Structural Priority

Priority is created in three ways, and most LBOs use more than one. Zeisberger, Prahl and White describe the combination of contractual and structural subordination (Mastering Private Equity, 2017, ch. 9); lien priority is the third piece.

Payment priority (contractual subordination) Lien priority Structural priority
What sets it A subordination clause or an intercreditor agreement Security documents and an intercreditor agreement Which company borrows, and which companies guarantee the debt
Question it answers Who is repaid first from any recovery? Who is repaid first from specific collateral? Whose assets can the lender reach at all?
Who waits behind whom The junior lender behind the senior lenders named in the agreement The second lien behind the first lien, on the shared collateral only A holding company lender with no guarantee from the operating company, behind every creditor of the operating company, suppliers included
Typical instruments Senior subordinated notes, European mezzanine First lien and second lien loans Holding company notes and PIK notes, bonds issued above the operating companies

Second lien debt shows why the distinction matters. It can rank equally with first lien debt in right of payment while ranking behind it on the collateral they share. Lawyers call that lien subordination: the first lien is repaid first from the proceeds of the shared collateral, and for recoveries from the borrower’s other assets the second lien ranks equally with the first lien and other senior creditors (Gibson Dunn, 2009). Payment subordination, by contrast, puts the junior debt behind the senior debt for every recovery, collateral or not.

John Gilligan and Mike Wright note that a buyout may set up several new holding companies precisely to give each source of funding its required priority (Private Equity Demystified, 2008, pp. 47-48). In the structure Zeisberger, Prahl and White describe, each funding instrument has its own vehicle: senior lenders at the bottom company, then a mezzanine vehicle, a shareholder loan vehicle and common equity. Cash passes up the chain only after each level’s lenders are paid. Here is the worked example below drawn as a group, with the subordinated notes at the operating company:

Who lends to whom: the worked example as a group structure
  1. Sponsor fundInvests the equity and owns 100% of HoldCo.
    • EquityEquity, $80MPaid last, from whatever is left after every creditor below.
  2. HoldCoA holding company with no operations. Its only asset is its OpCo shares.
    • JuniorHoldCo notes, if used (none in this example)Lend to HoldCo with no guarantee from OpCo, so they are paid only from what OpCo is allowed to pass up: structurally subordinated to every OpCo creditor.
  3. OpCo: Industrial Inc.The borrower. Owns the assets and earns the $25M of EBITDA.
    • SeniorSenior lenders, $60MA $55M term loan and the $5M revolver draw, with a first lien on OpCo's assets.
    • JuniorSubordinated noteholders, $20M at 12%Lend to OpCo too, but agree by contract to be repaid after the senior lenders: contractual subordination.
    • OperatingOperating creditorsSuppliers, employees, landlords and tax authorities, paid in the ordinary course.

Move the notes up to HoldCo, with no guarantee from OpCo, and they become structurally subordinated as well: behind OpCo's suppliers and every other OpCo creditor, not only behind the senior lenders.

How cash reaches each layer in a structured LBO
  1. Operating company earns the cashSuppliers, employees, taxes and other operating creditors are paid here first.
  2. Senior lenders are paidInterest and scheduled repayments on the bank debt at the borrowing company.
  3. Cash moves up to the mezzanine vehicleOnly what the senior debt agreements allow to be paid upward.
  4. Mezzanine and subordinated lenders are paidCash interest where the senior documents allow it; otherwise interest accrues as PIK, or waits while a senior default blocks payment.
  5. Shareholder loans, then equityPaid last, mostly at exit.

A debt pushdown, which moves the acquisition debt into the operating company, or guarantees from the operating companies give the senior lenders a direct claim on the operating assets, so they no longer wait behind trade creditors.

Roberto Ippolito describes the usual pattern: high-yield bonds are usually structurally subordinated, while mezzanine is usually placed at the operating company and subordinated by contract instead (Private Capital Investing, 2020, ch. 2). Treat that as a pattern, not a rule. Bonds guaranteed by the operating subsidiaries are direct creditors of those subsidiaries, and secured bonds come ahead of trade creditors on their collateral, so check the issuer, the guarantors and the collateral before ranking any tranche by its name.

Mezzanine and Second Lien

Mezzanine sits between senior debt and equity. Ippolito describes its usual features: a bullet repayment at maturity, interest partly deferred or paid in kind, and equity warrants that add to its all-in cost (ch. 2). That back-ended structure puts less strain on early cash flow than high-yield bonds, while the warrants make mezzanine more expensive than bonds over time.

The product also differs by market. European mezzanine is typically junior secured on the same collateral as the senior debt and subordinated by contract; US mezzanine is more often unsecured. Second lien debt is a lien arrangement rather than a payment subordination: it shares the first lien lenders’ collateral but ranks behind them on it, and its spread depends on the risk and terms of the particular facility.

Exhibit A

Who gets paid if the house case is sold for less

For this simplified recovery example, split $80 million of debt into $60 million of senior debt (a $55 million term loan and the $5 million revolver draw) and $20 million of 12% subordinated notes, both at the operating company, with the notes subordinated by contract. The sponsor still invests $80 million. The downloadable workbook instead has $79.5 million of senior borrowings at closing, including a $4.5 million revolver draw. The round numbers here make the recovery thresholds easy to read. Suppose the business is sold early, before any debt is repaid, at four prices, and the buyer takes on the trade payables with the business, and the amounts below are the cash available after sale costs and other prior claims:

Sale value Senior ($60M) Subordinated ($20M) Equity ($80M)
$160M $60M (100%) $20M (100%) $80M (1.0x)
$120M $60M (100%) $20M (100%) $40M (0.5x)
$70M $60M (100%) $10M (50%) $0
$50M $50M (83%) $0 $0
  1. Senior lenders lose money only below $60 million, 40% of the $150 million purchase price.
  2. Subordinated lenders start losing below $80 million and are wiped out at $60 million.
  3. At $160 million of distributable cash, equity gets $80 million. A decline to $80 million wipes out that residual. Fees paid at closing supply no recoverable collateral.
Recovery by layer at four sale valuesStacked columns showing who is paid at each sale value. At $160 million: senior $60 million, subordinated $20 million, equity $80 million. At $120 million: senior $60 million, subordinated $20 million, equity $40 million. At $70 million (highlighted): senior $60 million, subordinated $10 million, equity nothing. At $50 million: senior $50 million only.Recovery by layer at four sale valuesSenior debtSubordinated debtEquity$0M$50M$100M$150M$160M$160M sale$120M$120M sale$70M$70M sale$50M$50M saleIllustrative split of $80M of debt into $60M senior and $20M subordinated, at closingbalances.

Why Sponsors Use Subordinated Debt

Subordinated debt replaces equity, not senior debt. If senior lenders will lend only so much against a company’s cash flow, the sponsor fills the rest of the price with its own equity or with junior debt. Junior debt costs more than senior debt but less than the return equity needs, so it raises the sponsor’s return when the deal works.

Run the house case three ways, with the same price and operating plan:

Financing Year-1 interest EBITDA ÷ interest at close Base case Year-2 recession
$80M senior $7.05M 3.5x 3.06x, 25.1% 2.09x, 15.9%
$60M senior + $20M subordinated at 12% $7.65M 3.3x 3.02x, 24.8% 2.06x, 15.5%
$60M senior + $20M more equity $5.25M 4.8x 2.72x, 22.1% 1.95x, 14.3%
Sponsor IRR when senior lenders stop at $60M

Horizontal bars of base case sponsor IRR: 24.8% when the gap is filled with $20 million of 12% subordinated notes (highlighted) and 22.1% when it is filled with $20 million more equity. A reference line marks 25.1% for $80 million of senior debt.

  • Gap filled with sub debt24.8% (3.02x)
  • Gap filled with equity22.1% (2.72x)

All senior, 25.1%

Teaching schedule, same price and exit. Subordinated notes: 12% cash interest, bullet at exit.

At this purchase price and with these rates, $20 million of subordinated notes costs the sponsor about 0.3 points of IRR against all-senior debt, but saves 2.7 points against writing a bigger equity check. The cost is risk: interest cover at close falls from 4.8x to 3.3x, and in the recession case the subordinated notes still have to be repaid in full at exit.

Does the Sponsor’s Reputation Change the Terms?

Lenders do not price a buyout on the company alone. A chapter in Douglas Cumming’s Oxford Handbook of Private Equity (2012, p. 473) cites Demiroglu and James (2010), who find better lending terms for more reputable private equity sponsors. Christian Deger’s study of buyout funds adds a nuance: a fund’s recent performance acts as a short-term reputation signal, and lenders limit debt to funds whose recent results are weak, while top-quartile funds get financing more easily (Behind the Curve, 2013, ch. 6).

For a candidate, the practical point is modest: when a case gives you debt terms, they reflect the sponsor as well as the company, and a smaller or newer sponsor may not get the same package.

Capital structure traps

TrapWhat goes wrongHow to catch itFix
Treating all debt as one numberLeverage is quoted in total, and nobody can say which tranche is impaired in a downside.Ask for leverage through each tranche: senior, then total.Show senior and total leverage separately and the recovery by tranche.
Ignoring structural subordinationHolding company notes are modeled as if they ranked with the operating company's lenders.Draw the structure chart and mark which company each lender lends to and which companies guarantee it.Rank holding company debt that the operating company does not guarantee behind every creditor of the operating company.
Sweeping cash to the subordinated notesThe model prepays bonds or mezzanine that cannot be prepaid without a premium.Check prepayment and call protection terms tranche by tranche.Sweep only the prepayable bank debt; repay bullet tranches at maturity or exit.
Forgetting the warrantsMezzanine is costed at its coupon, and the equity waterfall ignores the lender's warrants.Look for a warrant or equity kicker in the term sheet.Include warrant dilution in the exit waterfall and the all-in cost of the debt.
Comparing coupons without feesTwo packages are compared on interest rate alone.Add arrangement fees, call premiums and PIK compounding.Compare the all-in cost over the expected hold.

Before you settle a capital structure

  • Each tranche's ranking, security, rate, repayment and covenants in one table.
  • A structure chart showing which company each lender lends to.
  • Senior and total leverage, and interest cover, at close and in the downside.
  • Recovery by tranche at three or four sale values.
  • The sweep applied only to prepayable debt.
  • Warrants and fees in the all-in cost and in the exit waterfall.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between senior and subordinated debt? At the same borrower, payment-subordinated debt ranks behind the senior claims named in the agreement. A lien separately establishes priority over particular collateral. A permitted junior coupon may be paid while senior debt remains outstanding. Read the payment blocks, guarantees and collateral schedules together.

What is the difference between contractual and structural subordination? Contractual subordination is a promise in an intercreditor agreement that a junior lender will be paid after the senior lender, even though both lend to the same company. Structural subordination comes from where the debt sits: a lender to a holding company that the operating company does not guarantee is paid only from what the operating company passes up after its own creditors, including trade creditors, are paid.

Why would a private equity firm use subordinated debt? A junior loan can cover the part of a purchase that senior lenders will not fund. In the illustrated structure, $20 million of 12% junior debt in place of additional sponsor equity raises base-case equity IRR from 22.1% to 24.8%. It also adds $2.4 million of annual cash interest and a $20 million exit obligation. The right choice depends on the cash the business can generate in a downside.

What is mezzanine debt? Mezzanine is subordinated debt that sits between senior debt and equity, usually with a bullet maturity, a mix of cash and PIK interest, and often equity warrants. In Europe it is typically junior secured and contractually subordinated at the operating company; US mezzanine is more often unsecured.

What is second lien debt? Second lien debt shares the first lien debt’s collateral but ranks behind it on that collateral, under an intercreditor agreement. It can still rank equally with the first lien in right of payment, which makes it a lien subordination rather than a payment subordination. Pricing also depends on maturity, collateral coverage, covenants and market conditions.

Do lenders give better terms to well-known private equity firms? Research suggests they do. Demiroglu and James (2010) find better lending terms for more reputable private equity sponsors, and Christian Deger finds that a fund’s recent performance acts as a short-term reputation signal: lenders give funds with weak recent results less access to debt.

Does PIK interest make debt junior? No. PIK describes how interest is paid, by adding it to principal instead of paying cash; it does not set where the debt ranks. Ranking comes from the subordination terms, the liens and the company that borrows. A senior loan can carry a PIK option, and a subordinated note can pay all of its interest in cash.

Sources

Books and frameworks (the tranche overview is a teaching pattern, not current market terms):

  • Claudia Zeisberger, Michael Prahl and Bowen White, Mastering Private Equity, 1st ed. (Wiley, 2017), ch. 9: structural and contractual subordination, the complex investment structure (Exhibit 9.3) and debt pushdowns.
  • Claudia Zeisberger, Michael Prahl and Bowen White, Private Equity in Action (Wiley, 2017), Case 12: Exhibit 12.6 (overview of debt in LBOs) and Exhibit 12.7 (the Avago debt structures, a historical deal).
  • John Gilligan and Mike Wright, Private Equity Demystified, 1st ed. (ICAEW Corporate Finance Faculty, 2008), section 3.1.3, pp. 47-48: Newcos and the priority of funding.
  • Roberto Ippolito, Private Capital Investing (Wiley, 2020), ch. 2: mezzanine, its structure and its comparison with high-yield bonds.

Legal commentary:

Research:

  • Cem Demiroglu and Christopher James, “The Role of Private Equity Group Reputation in LBO Financing,” Journal of Financial Economics 96(2), 2010, as summarized in Douglas Cumming (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Private Equity (Oxford University Press, 2012), p. 473.
  • Christian Deger, Behind the Curve: An Analysis of the Investment Behavior of Private Equity Funds (Diplomica, 2013), ch. 6.

Our calculations:

From the testBramblewick Seafood · The assignment

A recommended purchase price and transaction structure, from your reading of the memorandum and the financials

The structure is yours to choose: a working revolver, a PIK security and a term loan for growth capex, each with its own place in the stack.

Revision History

  1. : Qualified the historical term loan B covenant example for covenant-lite structures.
  2. : Verified the historical note coupons against Avago’s prospectus, reconciled the simplified recovery thresholds, and distinguished payment priority, collateral and the cash cost of junior debt.
  3. : First published, with a recovery waterfall and a financing comparison on the house distribution case.